Rent vs Finance Equipment: What’s the Smarter Choice?

If your business uses specialized equipment—construction tools, trucks, lifts, compressors, generators—you’ve likely faced this decision:

Should we keep renting… or finance and buy?

At first glance, renting may seem easier. It avoids long-term commitment and large capital outlays. But frequent or long-term rentals can quietly become more expensive than owning, especially when financing gives you flexible terms and tax benefits.

In this article, we’ll compare:

• The cost and control of renting vs. financing
• Scenarios where one clearly beats the other
• Tax implications of both approaches
• A real-world example
• A decision checklist to guide you

The Basics: Renting vs. Financing at a Glance

When Renting Makes Sense

Renting is a good fit when:

• You need the equipment for a specific project or short period
• The asset is expensive or highly specialized (e.g. a crane for one job)
• You want to test before you commit to owning
• You lack the storage or maintenance capacity
• The equipment is only used a few days a month

When Financing Becomes the Smarter Option

Financing wins out when:

• You use the equipment monthly or continuously
• Rental fees are eating into your margins
• You want to build business equity through ownership
• You need always-available access (no rental waitlists)
• Your accountant says it’s time to reduce taxable income via depreciation*

Example: Renting a skid steer at $450/day for 10 days/month = $4,500/month.
Financing the same unit might cost just $1,300–$1,800/month, depending on term and credit.

Real Case Study: A Landscaping Business Replaces Rentals with Financing

Business: Alberta-based landscaping and snow removal contractor
Need: Skid steer + snow pusher, used 6–8 months/year
Past Approach: Rented skid steer at $500/day or $2,000/week
Problem: Rental costs exceeded $22,000 per year, and availability issues caused job delays

Solution:
Financed a $58,000 used skid steer over 48 months
Monthly payment: $1,349
Bundled in extended warranty and delivery

Outcome:
Saved ~40% in annual costs. No more waiting on rentals.
Asset retained 45% value after 4 years.

Tax Implications: Rental vs. Financing

Renting:

• Treated as an operating expense
• Fully deductible in the year incurred
• Simpler for accounting

Financing:

• Loan interest is deductible
• Capital Cost Allowance (CCA) applies to asset depreciation
• May require tracking on the balance sheet
• Greater long-term tax advantages for high-use assets

Always consult your accountant about CCA and how your equipment class affects tax benefits.

Decision Checklist: Rent or Finance?

Use the list below to guide your next equipment decision:

✅ How often will you use it?
→ Monthly or year-round use often justifies financing

✅ How long will you need it?
→ Projects under 2–3 weeks may be better suited to rentals

✅ Do you want ownership or flexibility?
→ Ownership builds long-term equity; leasing still allows upgrades

✅ Can you afford the upfront cost?
→ Financing may offer $0 down structures or deferred payment

✅ Are rentals hard to book when you need them?
→ High-demand seasons often make financing worth it

✅ Does your accountant recommend tax write-offs or asset building?
→ Financing offers tax-efficient ownership in many cases

✅ Are you growing and need reliable access to tools or vehicles?
→ Financing secures dedicated gear for core operations

FAQs: Renting vs. Financing Business Equipment

Is leasing different from renting?
Yes. Leasing is a form of long-term financing. You make structured payments over time and may own the asset at the end. Renting is short-term and offers no ownership.

Can I finance used or auctioned equipment instead of renting?
Yes. Mehmi supports financing of used or private-sale equipment, with proper documentation.

Can I still write off financed equipment?
Yes. Through depreciation (CCA) and interest deductions, financed equipment offers tax benefits—just structured differently than rental deductions.

What if I only need the equipment for part of the year?
Consider seasonal financing or sale-leaseback to maximize flexibility without paying full price year-round.

Final Word: Smart Access, Smarter Ownership

Renting offers short-term flexibility.
But for high-usage or essential assets, financing usually wins in both cost and control.

At Mehmi, we help you evaluate the total cost of use—so you can make the right call between renting, financing, or a mix of both.

Want help crunching the numbers to see if financing beats renting for your business?
Talk to a credit analyst or use our calculator to compare scenarios and lock in flexible terms that suit your operations.

‍