Quick answer: A $1 buyout lease can suit a business that expects to keep the equipment, while an FMV lease may suit a planned replacement or a decision to buy later. Compare the actual contract: total payments, purchase terms, return conditions and early-exit obligations. An FMV payment that looks lower is not automatically cheaper if you ultimately buy the asset. Neither label alone establishes accounting or tax treatment.
Disclaimer: This article is general information only and is not tax, legal or accounting advice. Tax rules change and depend on your situation. Speak with a qualified accountant or tax advisor before making any purchase or filing decision. Mehmi Financial Group does not provide tax advice.
Reviewed November 11, 2026.
Key takeaways
- Decide whether continued ownership or replacement is the likely goal.
- Read the fixed-buyout and FMV clauses in full.
- Compare the cost of the same end result, including return or purchase expenses.
- Confirm notice dates and completion documents before the lease ends.
What the dollar-buyout arrangement offers
A dollar-buyout structure specifies a nominal purchase amount, commonly $1, subject to the contract's conditions. Its attraction is a more defined ownership plan. That does not mean the business's total cost is just the regular payments plus one dollar in every transaction.
Ask about fees, outstanding obligations, required notices and the documents needed to complete the arrangement. Confirm when legal title transfers and what security or other rights remain until obligations are satisfied. Avoid assuming that every provider uses identical legal wording.
Our dollar-buyout explainer covers this structure in more detail. Use it to prepare questions, then review the actual proposed documents.
What an FMV arrangement requires you to decide
FMV means fair market value. Where the contract offers an FMV purchase option, the amount payable to buy the equipment is determined under the agreement's valuation process rather than being a nominal fixed amount stated at the beginning.
Ask who determines that value, what information is used and how a disagreement is resolved. Find out when the purchase quotation becomes available and how long it remains valid. A verbal expectation of a modest buyout is not a contractual price.
Check whether return and renewal are actually available and what conditions apply. Do not treat FMV as a promise that you can walk away whenever you want. The options at scheduled maturity can be very different from the rights during the initial term.
Match the end state to the equipment
If the business expects to use a machine for many years and the installation is expensive to remove, a defined ownership route may be attractive. Verify that the equipment is likely to remain useful and supportable through that period.
If replacement is planned, examine the return process and the next equipment purchase together. A technology refresh can involve data migration, operator training and a period of overlapping costs. Returning the old equipment does not provide the replacement automatically.
For uncertain plans, price more than one scenario. Calculate what happens if you keep, return or need to exit early. The best choice is the one that fits the likely business outcomes at an acceptable cost, not simply the one that advertises more options.
Make the cash comparison complete
| Cost or condition | $1 buyout question | FMV question |
|---|---|---|
| Initial cash | What payments and fees are due before delivery? | What payments and deposits are due before delivery? |
| Regular schedule | How many payments are included? | How many payments are included? |
| Keeping the asset | What must be completed beyond the nominal amount? | How will the purchase amount be established? |
| Replacing the asset | What sale or transfer restrictions apply? | What notice, condition and freight obligations apply? |
| Changing plans early | What is the settlement method? | What is the settlement or termination method? |
Keep advance payments inside the count where they are already included. Identify refundable deposits separately. Make sure the equipment and service package is identical, or clearly reconcile the differences before comparing totals.
Ask for a written schedule rather than relying on a payment factor alone. Fees, timing and the final amount affect the commercial cost. Our lease payment and cost guide can help organize the arithmetic.
Use a break-even question for the purchase option
Consider two invented offers for the same equipment over 36 months. The dollar-buyout offer has 36 payments of $1,400 plus $1, for $50,401. The FMV offer has 36 payments of $1,200, for $43,200 before any purchase amount.
The difference is $7,201. With all other costs assumed equal, that is the FMV purchase amount at which the stated cash totals would match. A lower purchase amount would produce a lower stated total; a higher one would produce a higher total. This is a comparison threshold, not a prediction of the equipment's market value.
The example excludes fees, taxes, initial payments outside the schedule and time value of money. It also assumes both paths can produce ownership on the stated terms. Use complete written quotes and an adviser-assisted analysis for the real decision.
Price the return option honestly
Read the required return location and condition standards. Ask about inspection, cleaning, missing components, repairs and transportation. For installed equipment, determine who disconnects and removes it and whether the premises need restoration.
Check the notice deadline and delivery deadline separately. Sending a notice may not complete the return. Keep records of instructions, collection arrangements and acceptance so there is evidence of what happened.
Budget the overlap with replacement equipment. The business may need the new machine operating before the old one leaves. If continuity matters, include that coordination in the purchase timetable rather than assuming an instant exchange.
Review early changes before they become urgent
Ask what would happen if a customer contract ended, the business moved or the equipment stopped meeting its needs. A scheduled FMV purchase option does not necessarily set the price of an early buyout. A nominal final buyout does not necessarily make early settlement inexpensive.
Request the method for obtaining a dated settlement quotation and identify any transfer restrictions. If someone suggests that another business could take over payments, confirm the formal approval and release process. Handing over the equipment does not by itself resolve your obligations.
Keep an early-change scenario in the cash forecast. If it would be unaffordable, that limitation should influence the initial choice rather than being left for a later negotiation.
Separate tax, accounting and ownership questions
CRA's leasing guidance describes deductible business leasing costs and a conditional election for certain arrangements. Do not assume every dollar-buyout contract produces the same deduction or every FMV payment is deductible in full.
Accounting treatment also depends on the relevant framework and agreement. Under IFRS 16, lessees generally recognize a right-of-use asset and liability, with qualifying exemptions. An FMV label does not establish off-balance-sheet treatment.
Give the accountant the complete proposed contract before signing. Our capital and operating lease comparison explains why the commercial choice and accounting classification should be reviewed separately.
Frequently asked questions
Is the dollar-buyout payment always higher?
Do not assume so without comparable quotes. Equipment cost, term, fees, credit review and other conditions affect the payment. Compare the whole schedule.
Can I buy an FMV asset cheaply at the end?
The contract's valuation process controls the purchase amount. Do not budget on an unsupported discount or assume the value will equal a percentage mentioned informally.
Can I change structures halfway through?
Only if the applicable agreement and parties permit the change. Ask about amendment or settlement options, including cost, rather than assuming conversion is available.
Which suits equipment I want to keep?
A defined purchase route may provide useful certainty, but compare total cost, conditions and expected use. Review the FMV purchase scenario too if it is a serious alternative.
Tools and next steps
Write down the intended end state, obtain both complete offers and calculate keep, return and early-change scenarios. Identify any unknown purchase or return amount before making the decision.
To discuss the available structures for your equipment, contact Mehmi Financial Group or call 1-833-863-4644.
Disclaimer: This article is general information only and is not tax, legal or accounting advice. Tax rules change and depend on your situation. Speak with a qualified accountant or tax advisor before making any purchase or filing decision. Mehmi Financial Group does not provide tax advice.
Sources
- CRA: Leasing costs.
- IFRS Foundation: IFRS 16 Leases. Reviewed November 11, 2026. All comparison figures are hypothetical.
By Jodhbir Mehmi. Read our editorial standards.
