Quick answer: A 10% buyout lease gives you the option to buy the equipment at the end of the term for 10% of its original cost. Monthly payments are usually lower than a $1 buyout lease and higher than a fair market value (FMV) lease. It fits best when you expect to keep the equipment, it will last well past the term, and you can plan for the final payment. It fits poorly when the equipment may go out of date quickly or when you are choosing it only to get the lowest monthly number.
Disclaimer: This article is general information only and is not tax, legal or accounting advice. Tax rules change and depend on your situation. Speak with a qualified accountant or tax advisor before making any purchase or filing decision. Mehmi Financial Group does not provide tax advice.
What a 10% buyout lease is
In a 10% buyout lease, the end-of-term purchase option is fixed at 10% of the original equipment price. On a $100,000 machine, the buyout would be $10,000, and you know that number on the day you sign.
That puts it between the two other common structures. An FMV lease leaves the final price open, to be set by the equipment's market value at the end. A $1 buyout lease is almost full ownership from the start, since nearly all of the cost is paid through the monthly payments. A 10% buyout leaves part of the equipment's value as a residual, which lowers the payment, while still giving you a known number at the end.
Lenders and brokers like it because it balances payment size against certainty. You get a lower payment than a $1 buyout without the open question an FMV lease leaves you with.
Why the structure exists
Businesses want different balances between monthly cost and end-of-term certainty. Push more of the cost into the monthly payments, as a $1 buyout does, and the payments rise but the end is simple. Leave more to the end, as an FMV lease does, and the payments fall but the final ownership cost is unknown. A 10% buyout splits the difference.
That makes the choice about structure more than about rate. Two quotes at the same rate can produce very different monthly payments and total costs depending on the residual.
FMV vs 10% buyout vs $1 buyout
FeatureFMV lease10% buyout lease$1 buyout leaseMonthly paymentLowestMiddleHighestEnd-of-term priceMarket value at the time, unknown at signingFixed at 10% of original costA nominal amount, such as $1Certainty at the endLowHighHighestBest whenYou may return or upgrade the equipmentYou probably want to keep it but want a lower paymentYou know you will keep it long termMain riskBuyout price higher than you expectedFinal payment that is hard to fund if you have not plannedHighest monthly cash commitment
The most common mistake is comparing only the monthly payment and ignoring the last one. That is how a business picks a lease that feels cheap for 60 months and expensive in month 61. Our guide to $1 vs FMV vs fixed buyout options covers the full comparison.
How the numbers shift
Take a $100,000 piece of equipment on a 60-month term. With a $1 buyout, almost all $100,000 is repaid through the monthly payments. With a 10% buyout, about $90,000 of the cost is spread over the payments and $10,000 is left for the end, so each payment is lower. With FMV, the residual is set by the lender's estimate of future value, so the payment is usually lowest, but your final price depends on the market. Actual payments depend on the rate, fees and your file. Our equipment financing calculator lets you test different scenarios.
When a 10% buyout lease makes sense
This structure fits best when you lean toward ownership but do not want the highest monthly payment. Good fits often include:
- Equipment with a useful life well beyond the lease term
- Assets you expect to keep running after the lease ends
- Machinery with a steady resale market, where FMV pricing would not offer much of an advantage
- Businesses that want certainty without paying the full cost through the monthly payments
- Projects where keeping cash in the business still matters
Put simply, it suits a business saying, "We probably want this equipment for the long term, but monthly affordability still matters."
When it is the wrong choice
A 10% buyout makes one part of the future predictable. That does not make it safe in every case. It is often a weaker fit when:
- The equipment may become obsolete quickly
- You are not sure how much you will use it
- You may not want it at the end of the term
- Cash is tight enough that a 10% final payment would turn into a refinancing problem
- The equipment is so central and durable that a $1 buyout would have been simpler from the start
Some businesses pick a 10% buyout when they really want a $1 buyout, because the payment looks better. That can work, but only with a real plan for the final payment, such as setting money aside each month or arranging to finance the buyout in advance.
What lenders look at
Lenders approve a 10% buyout lease when the overall risk makes sense, not because the structure sounds reasonable. The 5 Cs are still the clearest way to see how they think.
Character
This covers management and payment behaviour. Lenders want complete documents, realistic expectations, a clean payment record and owners who understand how the equipment will be used.
Capacity
This is your ability to make the payment, and it carries the most weight. The lender wants to see that the business can carry the lease comfortably now, not only in its best month.
Capital
This is the owner's own money in the business: a down payment, retained earnings, a stronger balance sheet, or cash left over after closing.
Collateral
In leasing, the equipment matters a great deal. Lessors prefer assets that hold their value and are easy to resell, because the equipment is their main protection if payments stop.
Conditions
This is everything around the deal: the industry, the type of equipment, whether this is a startup, expansion, replacement or refinance, and whether the term fits the equipment's working life.
Lenders are really asking three things. How likely is the borrower to struggle? How much money is at risk if they do? How much could be recovered by selling the equipment?
How the lender sees the residual
The 10% residual means part of the equipment cost is not repaid through the monthly payments. That lowers the payment, but it makes some things more important to the lender:
- The condition of the equipment
- How much working life it will have left
- Its likely resale value at the end of the term
- Whether you are likely to exercise the buyout
That is why lenders want the term, down payment and residual stated up front. Those three numbers shape both the payment and the risk.
Canadian tax points to raise with your accountant
A 10% buyout lease is a tax and accounting decision as well as a payment decision. CRA's guidance on leasing costs says lease payments for property used in your business can generally be deducted as leasing costs. CRA also explains that, in some lease arrangements, the parties can jointly elect to treat lease payments as combined payments of principal and interest. If you own the equipment instead, the cost is usually recovered through capital cost allowance. CRA lists the CCA classes and rates, and many types of general business equipment fall into Class 8 at a 20% rate, depending on the asset.
For manufacturing or processing machinery, federal Budget 2025 reinstated the Accelerated Investment Incentive and immediate expensing. Whether that applies depends on the asset and whether you are treated as the owner.
Many business owners assume a 10% buyout lease will automatically get the treatment they expect. It might, but the answer depends on the contract and how your business reports. Do not choose between FMV, 10% and $1 based on what someone told you at a trade show. Ask your accountant before you sign.
Documents that strengthen a 10% buyout file
A good structure does not rescue a weak file. Plan to provide:
Smaller dealsLarger deals may also needSigned credit applicationAccountant-prepared financial statementsFull equipment specifications or vendor quoteRecent interim financial statementsVendor's legal nameBusiness bank statementsShort summary of the businessA write-up on your industry or contractsProposed term, down payment and residualExtra support for startups or specialized industries
A startup should have at least 6 months of revenue in its business bank statements before applying. A 10% residual does not reduce the need to prove the business can make the payments. For more, see our documents needed for equipment financing in Canada.
Conditions before funding and obligations after
Conditions precedent are what must be in place before the lender pays the vendor. On a lease, that usually means signed documents, proof of insurance, the vendor invoice, a void cheque, ID and proof of any deposit.
After funding, some leases include ongoing reporting obligations, such as providing annual financial statements. Lenders use these to spot strain early, before a payment is missed. Generally, the higher the risk, the more monitoring and security a lender asks for.
An example
Here is a hypothetical example. An Ontario manufacturer wants a CNC machine priced at $180,000 and is comparing FMV, 10% buyout and $1 buyout structures. The business is profitable but carries inventory and gets paid unevenly by customers, so it wants to keep working capital. The owner expects to run the machine well beyond five years but does not want the highest payment.
The $1 buyout feels too tight on monthly cash flow. The FMV lease is cheaper month to month, but the owner does not like not knowing the final price. A 10% buyout fits: the machine will outlast the term, the company has steady capacity to pay, the owner plans to keep it, and an $18,000 buyout is a known amount the business can save toward. See our CNC machine financing page for more on this equipment type.
Five questions to decide
- Are we very likely to keep this equipment at the end?
- If so, would we rather pay more each month so the end costs almost nothing?
- If not, are we comfortable with an FMV price we will not know until later?
- If we choose 10%, will the final payment be manageable, or will it turn into a refinancing conversation?
- Will the equipment hold up well enough that a middle-ground residual makes sense?
If you cannot answer these clearly, hold off on choosing a structure until you can. We can help you test the options against your cash flow before you sign. Approval, rates and amounts are subject to lender review.
Tools and next steps
- Loan vs lease comparison calculator
- Equipment financing calculator
- 10% purchase option lease: how buyouts work
- $1 buyout lease vs FMV lease in Canada
- Equipment leases
Ready to see whether a 10% buyout lease fits your equipment? Talk to a financing advisor or call 1-833-863-4644.
Disclaimer: This article is general information only and is not tax, legal or accounting advice. Tax rules change and depend on your situation. Speak with a qualified accountant or tax advisor before making any purchase or filing decision. Mehmi Financial Group does not provide tax advice.
Sources
- CRA: Leasing costs
- CRA: Classes of depreciable property
- CRA: Business expenses
- Prime Minister of Canada: Budget 2025 measures
- BDC: Equipment financing 101
Written by Jodh Mehmi, Mehmi Financial Group. Read our editorial standards.
Frequently asked questions
Is a 10% buyout lease the same as a finance lease?
Not always in a strict accounting or tax sense. Because the purchase price is fixed, it often sits closer to ownership than an FMV lease, but the treatment depends on the contract and your reporting framework. Confirm it with your accountant.
Is the 10% based on the original price or the remaining balance?
Usually the original equipment cost. Check the agreement to confirm how the buyout is calculated.
Are payments lower on a 10% buyout than a $1 buyout?
Usually, yes. Leaving 10% of the cost as a residual means less is repaid through the monthly payments. Payments are usually higher than an FMV lease, though.
Is a 10% buyout lease better than FMV?
It depends on your plans. It is usually the better choice if you want certainty about the final price. It is usually the weaker choice if you may not want the equipment at the end or if it may go out of date quickly.
Can I return the equipment instead of buying it?
Some 10% purchase option leases let you return the equipment instead, but the contract decides. Do not assume every lender offers the same exit options. Read the end-of-term section before you sign.
Does GST/HST apply to lease payments in Canada?
Generally, sales tax is charged on lease payments. CRA guidance says GST/HST you pay can form part of a deductible expense, net of any input tax credits you claim. The exact treatment depends on the asset and your tax position, so check with your accountant.
