Quick answer: Choose a $1 buyout lease if you plan to keep the equipment for most of its useful life and want a clean path to ownership. Choose a fair market value (FMV) lease if you want lower payments and the option to return or upgrade, and you are genuinely open to handing the equipment back. Compare the two on total cost including the likely end-of-term outcome, because the lower FMV payment can be offset by a buyout later. Approval, rates and amounts are subject to lender review.
Disclaimer: This article is general information only and is not tax, legal or accounting advice. Tax rules change and depend on your situation. Speak with a qualified accountant or tax advisor before making any purchase or filing decision. Mehmi Financial Group does not provide tax advice.
If you want the short explainers first, read what a $1 buyout lease means and our FMV lease guide. This article is the decision guide: when each structure works, how lenders see them, where Canadian tax rules come in and how to avoid paying for flexibility you will never use.
The short version: ownership certainty or exit flexibility
A $1 buyout lease is built for ownership. An FMV lease is built for options. With a $1 structure you pay the equipment down over the term because you expect to keep it. With FMV, the lessor expects the equipment to still be worth something at the end, so your monthly payments are lower because you are not paying off its full value.
$1 buyout leaseFMV leaseMonthly paymentHigherLowerEnd of termBuy for a nominal amountReturn, renew or buy at market valueWho carries residual riskMostly youMostly the lessorTotal cost if you keep itKnown from day oneDepends on the buyout price at the endBest forCore, long-life equipmentEquipment you may replace or that ages quickly
When a $1 buyout lease makes sense
A $1 buyout is about predictable long-term control. If you are financing a truck, trailer, machine or production line you expect to run well past the lease term, it matches how you will actually use the asset. You are leasing to preserve cash and spread the payments, and you still end up owning the unit.
That is why many operators treat the $1 buyout as the standard lease-to-own option. The payment is higher because the residual is nominal, but it buys clarity. There is no valuation argument at the end, no market-value negotiation and no fight over return condition on an asset you always meant to keep.
A lot of "$1 or FMV?" questions are really "am I financing ownership or financing use?" Our guides on equipment leasing vs financing and lease vs buy equipment in Canada help with that bigger question.
Be honest about your intent. Plenty of owners tell themselves they might return an asset later, then keep it for years. If that sounds like you, the FMV structure only looks cheaper because part of the cost is waiting at the end.
When an FMV lease makes sense
FMV works best when the asset's future value is uncertain or your future need for it is uncertain. That includes technology-heavy equipment, some medical devices, office systems, specialty units and equipment tied to a contract you may not renew. Lower payments now, plus the option to hand it back, can be worth a lot in those cases.
FMV also suits businesses that are growing quickly, testing a new service line or trying not to get stuck with outdated equipment. See short-term equipment leasing for projects and seasonal needs. The catch is simple: FMV only saves money if you actually use the flexibility.
The real difference is residual risk
People often compare these two as if they were two payment quotes. They split risk differently. With a $1 buyout you absorb most of the asset's loss in value during the term. With FMV, the lessor assumes the asset will still be worth something later, and that assumption is what lowers your payment. That is why lenders care so much about resale strength, usage, condition and market depth on FMV deals.
Here is a hypothetical example to show the logic (the figures are made up for illustration and are not a quote). On a $100,000 machine over 60 months, the FMV lease has a noticeably lower payment than the $1 buyout. If the machine is worth around $20,000 at the end and you decide to keep it, you pay that amount on top of the FMV payments. Depending on the pricing, your all-in cost can land close to the $1 buyout, and sometimes above it. FMV only wins clearly when you return or renew. If ownership is the likely outcome, model the probable buyout before calling the lower payment better.
When you compare real quotes, keep our equipment lease rates guide open. Many owners compare a lease rate, a factor and a payment without adjusting for the end-of-term obligation.
Canadian tax changes the picture
Do not pick a structure based on a one-line tax rule. CRA's guidance on leasing costs says lease payments incurred in the year for property used in the business are generally deductible. It also says that, if both parties agree, lease payments can instead be treated as combined principal and interest. In that case, the interest may be deductible and the property may be eligible for capital cost allowance (CCA). CRA also makes clear that when you buy depreciable property, you generally cannot deduct the full cost in the year you buy it, and you claim CCA instead.
So "lease payments are fully deductible" does not settle the question. The tax result depends on the actual structure, the documents, the equipment, your business use and any election. Budget 2025 (November 4, 2025) also reinstated the Accelerated Investment Incentive and immediate expensing for manufacturing or processing machinery and equipment through the Productivity Super-Deduction, which can affect the case for owning. See our guides on capital lease tax treatment and HST/GST on equipment leases.
On sales tax, CRA says the GST/HST rate on a sale, lease or other taxable supply depends on place-of-supply rules, and eligible registrants can generally claim input tax credits for GST/HST paid on expenses used in commercial activities. If your business is fully taxable and properly registered, much of the sales tax on lease payments may be recoverable. The timing still affects cash flow.
How lenders look at the choice
Lenders start with risk, not your preference. They ask three questions. How likely is it that you stop paying? How much will still be owed if you do? How much can be recovered from the equipment and any guarantees?
The 5 Cs put this in plain terms. Character is whether you pay as agreed and raise problems early. Capacity is whether the business can carry the payment through a normal slow month. Capital is the financial strength and owner support in the deal. Collateral is the equipment and how recoverable it is. Conditions are the industry, the economy and the terms of the deal.
That lens can push a file one way. If the equipment is highly specialized, loses value unpredictably or will be heavily used, FMV residual assumptions get harder to support. If cash flow is tight but the business clearly needs the asset long term, a longer $1 structure can be easier to justify than an FMV lease that leaves an awkward question at the end. A broker may also point you to a different source of capital depending on the file; see BDC vs bank equipment financing.
Before funding and after
A deal is funded when the conditions are met, not when the approval email arrives. That usually means clear equipment specs, a proper vendor invoice or bill of sale, signed lease documents, insurance, banking details and anything extra the credit team asked for based on the asset, its age, the amount or your profile. Recent bank statements and financials help files move.
After funding, lenders watch for early warning signs: late financial statements, pressure on bank balances, sudden drops in revenue, insurance lapses, falling asset values, covenant breaches or a story that keeps changing. Staying transparent is the easiest way to keep your options open later.
A common pattern
An owner gets two proposals for a core piece of equipment: an FMV lease with a clearly lower payment and a $1 buyout with a higher one. The FMV looks like the obvious winner. But the owner already expects to keep the unit for seven years or more, it is central to daily work and it will be heavily used, which makes return condition and residual value awkward. Once the likely buyout is added, the FMV quote looks deferred rather than cheap. In that situation the $1 buyout usually fits better: a higher payment, simpler budgeting and no end-of-term valuation on a machine the owner never planned to return.
Choosing in ten minutes
Ask yourself three questions. Do I want to own this asset or just use it? If I chose FMV, what is my most likely outcome at the end: return, renew or buy? If I chose $1, am I comfortable paying more each month for simpler ownership later? Honest answers usually point to the right structure.
Common mistakes
The first mistake is shopping by monthly payment only. The second is assuming tax settles the answer automatically. The third is ignoring how the lender sees residual and documentation risk. The fourth is choosing the structure before the equipment's role is clear. If the asset is temporary, pilot-stage, seasonal or easy to replace, FMV can be smart. If it is core, durable and central to revenue, a $1 buyout is usually the more honest structure.
Mehmi Financial Group works with over 50 lenders and can review a quote's structure, end-of-term exposure and approval logic before you sign. Approval, rates and amounts are subject to lender review.
Tools and next steps
- Equipment leases
- Loan vs lease comparison calculator
- $1 buyout vs FMV vs fixed buyout: how to choose
- Early payout calculator for leases
Ready to compare a $1 buyout and an FMV quote side by side? Talk to a financing advisor or call 1-833-863-4644.
Disclaimer: This article is general information only and is not tax, legal or accounting advice. Tax rules change and depend on your situation. Speak with a qualified accountant or tax advisor before making any purchase or filing decision. Mehmi Financial Group does not provide tax advice.
Sources
- CRA: Leasing costs
- CRA: Input tax credits
- CRA: Charge and collect the tax, which rate to charge
- Prime Minister of Canada: Budget 2025 measures (November 7, 2025)
- BDC: Equipment financing 101
- ISED Canada: Canada Small Business Financing Program
Written by Jodh Mehmi, Mehmi Financial Group. Read our editorial standards.
Frequently asked questions
Is a $1 buyout lease always better for trucks and heavy equipment?
Not always, but often. If the unit is core to the business and you expect to keep it for years, the $1 structure usually matches what really happens. FMV can still work when you expect turnover or upgrades.
Does an FMV lease always have the lower payment?
Usually, yes. Lower does not mean cheaper overall. If you buy the asset at the end, the total cost can come close to a $1 buyout, depending on the residual and the quote.
Are lease payments tax deductible in Canada?
CRA says lease payments for business-use property are generally deductible, but it also allows some leases to be treated as principal and interest if both parties agree, which changes the treatment. Ask your accountant.
Do you pay GST/HST on equipment lease payments?
In a typical taxable commercial lease, yes, based on place-of-supply rules. Eligible GST/HST registrants can generally claim input tax credits for business use.
Which lease is easier to get approved?
There is no universal winner. It depends on the borrower, the asset, the industry, the term and how believable the residual is.
What documents help the approval move?
Clear equipment specs, a vendor invoice or bill of sale, the signed application or lease documents, recent bank statements, financials where required, insurance and a short explanation of how the equipment supports the business.
