Quick answer: The buyout is your plan for the end of the lease, and it changes your payment, how a lender sees the deal and your real total cost. Choose a $1 buyout if you are almost sure you will keep the equipment for a long time. Choose FMV (fair market value) if you want the lowest payment and the option to return or upgrade. Choose a fixed buyout, such as 10% or 20% of the original cost, if you want a known end cost with a lower payment than a $1 buyout. Approval, rates and amounts are subject to lender review.
Disclaimer: This article is general information only and is not tax, legal or accounting advice. Tax rules change and depend on your situation. Speak with a qualified accountant or tax advisor before making any purchase or filing decision. Mehmi Financial Group does not provide tax advice.
This guide explains how each buyout works, how underwriters think about them, how to compare quotes when the buyouts differ and the Canadian tax points that catch owners off guard.
What "buyout" means in an equipment lease
A lease is a contract with an end-of-term option, and that option is usually one of three:
- A $1 buyout, sometimes called a token buyout
- An FMV buyout, where you buy at whatever the asset is worth at the end, or return it
- A fixed buyout, a pre-set amount that is often a percentage of the original cost
The lessor prices the deal based on how much value it expects to recover if it ever has to take the equipment back or if you return it. That is why the buyout matters so much. For background on who offers which structures, see Canadian equipment leasing companies.
$1 buyoutFixed buyoutFMVMonthly paymentHighestMiddleUsually lowestEnd costNominalKnown in advanceUnknown until the endResidual riskMostly yoursSharedMostly the lessor'sEnd-of-term optionsOwn itBuy at the set price, or as the contract allowsReturn, renew or buy at FMVBest forLong-life core equipmentProbably keeping it, not certainUpgrades, tech change, uncertain use
Why the buyout changes approval and pricing
Buyouts shift who holds the risk at the end, your business or the lessor, and that risk shows up in the payment, fees and conditions. Underwriters think about three things: the chance the borrower misses payments, how much is owed if that happens, and how much they lose after reselling the equipment.
The buyout mostly affects that last part. On an FMV lease the lessor is betting on the residual value, so it cares a lot about the asset type, the resale market and wear. On a $1 buyout the deal behaves more like paying the asset down to almost nothing, so the lessor relies more on your ability to pay across the term. A fixed buyout shares the risk: the lessor still has some residual exposure, and you commit to a known amount at the end. That is why lenders want the term, down payment and residual or buyout set out clearly in the credit request.
$1 buyout: when you are keeping the asset
A $1 buyout commits you to ownership. Payments are higher and there are fewer surprises at the end. It is a strong fit when you expect to keep the equipment beyond the term, when it is not very sensitive to obsolescence, when you will put heavy hours on it and when you want a simple plan that ends with ownership. It works well for core production equipment.
The trade-offs: higher payments because there is little or no residual holding them down, and early payout rules that can be expensive if you upgrade early, since some lessors expect most of the remaining payments. Plan for sales tax at the buyout too. Even at $1, other fees or taxable amounts may apply depending on the contract and your province.
On income tax, a lessee and lessor can in some situations jointly elect under section 16.1 of the Income Tax Act to treat a lease more like a financed purchase. That can affect whether you claim capital cost allowance and treat payments as blended principal and interest. See capital lease tax treatment: CCA vs lease deductions.
FMV buyout: when flexibility matters
FMV is usually the lowest-payment structure because you are not paying the whole asset down. You pay for use and the lessor holds the residual risk. At the end you typically return the equipment, buy it at FMV or renew. FMV often suits you if you might upgrade in 3 to 5 years, if the equipment is exposed to technology change (IT, CNC controls, medical technology, specialty production), if your use is uncertain because the business is seasonal or contract-based, or if cash flow today matters most.
The downsides: the end cost is unknown until the end, returns can come with conditions on wear, damage, missing components, transport and inspection, and disputes happen when "market value" is not clearly defined.
The most common FMV trap is choosing it for the low payment while quietly assuming you will buy it cheaply later. Sometimes that works. Sometimes the FMV comes in higher than expected, especially on equipment that holds its value, and you either pay more than planned or refinance the buyout under pressure. If you choose FMV, plan three scenarios now: return, buy and renew.
Fixed buyout: the middle ground
A fixed purchase option lets you buy at the end for a preset amount, commonly a percentage of the original cost. A 10% purchase option is the classic example, and it typically sits between FMV and a $1 buyout on monthly payment. It fits when you will probably keep the asset but are not certain, want to avoid FMV surprises, want a lower payment than a $1 buyout and expect the asset to hold reasonable value.
Two pitfalls: if the asset loses value faster than expected, you may be committed to a buyout above market value. And a fixed buyout does not always mean an easy return, so check the contract.
Six questions to choose your buyout
QuestionLean $1Lean fixedLean FMVHow long will you realistically keep it?7+ years, run it into the groundUnsure3 to 5 years, likely upgradeCore tool or project-based?Core production toolCore, with some doubtProject or contract-drivenWhat if it is the wrong fit in 24 months?You can redeploy or resell easilyYou can redeploy or resell easilyA wrong fit would hurt badlyHow sensitive is your cash flow?You can afford more for certaintyModerateYou need the lowest paymentWhat is the real resale picture?Matters lessStrong and stable helpsStrong and stable helps pricingWhat does your accountant prefer?AskAskAsk
On tax preference: leasing costs are generally deductible as leasing costs under CRA guidance, and Canada has special rules, including the joint election, that can let certain lease payments be treated as blended principal and interest.
How to compare quotes with different buyouts
You cannot compare payments unless you also compare the end-of-term obligation. Work out two totals for each offer:
- Total cost to own: monthly payment times term, plus upfront fees, the buyout amount and any end fees
- Total cost to use: monthly payment times term, plus upfront fees, return costs and any end fees
Then ask: am I buying a low payment now with a big decision later? Our guides on equipment lease rates in Canada and deferred payment equipment financing help you check the rest of the offer.
Red flags before you sign
Most buyout problems are really contract language problems. Watch for:
- FMV with no clear definition. If the agreement does not say how FMV is set (appraisal, market listings or lessor discretion), treat that as a risk.
- "It is basically a $1 buyout" when the paper says FMV or fixed. Only the contract counts.
- Automatic renewal or rollover language. Know what happens if you do nothing at the end.
- Mandatory purchase language, where the end of the term requires you to buy. That is a different risk from a true FMV option.
- Early payout terms that block an upgrade. Some lessors expect the remaining payments, or close to it, if you exit early. Get the rules in writing.
Canadian tax points to plan for
Sales tax and input tax credits change cash flow, and buyouts often trigger tax again.
GST/HST rates
The rate depends on CRA's place-of-supply rules, and participating provinces have different HST rates. Nova Scotia's HST rate changed to 14% on April 1, 2025.
Input tax credits
If you are a GST/HST registrant using the equipment in commercial activities, you may be able to claim input tax credits. The quick method has its own rules.
Quebec
Revenu Québec notes that for long-term leases of road vehicles, GST and QST are collected on lease payments, and the lessor must also collect GST and QST if the lessee exercises the purchase option.
Treating the lease like a purchase
CRA explains that for certain lease agreements you can choose, with the lessor's agreement, to treat payments as blended principal and interest, under the framework in section 16.1 of the Income Tax Act. Budget 2025 (November 4, 2025) also reinstated the Accelerated Investment Incentive and immediate expensing for manufacturing or processing machinery and equipment through the Productivity Super-Deduction, which can affect the case for owning. Talk to your accountant before you pick a buyout for tax reasons.
Which buyouts are easier to approve?
Approval depends on structure fit and a complete file as well as credit. With strong credit and strong financials, any structure can work and the buyout becomes a business decision. With tighter cash flow or a newer business, FMV can help affordability, but lenders may be cautious about the asset type and condition. Startups need at least 6 months of revenue in their business bank statements. On used or older assets, lenders look hard at condition and resale, and the structure has to match the collateral.
Getting the deal funded
Whatever buyout you choose, funding depends on clearing the conditions. Most equipment funding packages need signed lease documents, ID for the signers and any guarantors, a void cheque or pre-authorized debit form, the vendor invoice or bill of sale with the vendor's banking details, and an insurance certificate. For the wider approval picture, read can you be denied a secured business loan?
A worked scenario
Take a contracting company buying a used excavator from a mainstream brand. Cash flow is strong but seasonal, and the job mix three years out is uncertain. It is choosing between FMV (lowest payment), a 10% fixed buyout (middle payment, known end cost) and a $1 buyout (highest payment, certain ownership). The questions to test: will the business keep the excavator beyond five years or move to a different size? What happens if utilization drops? Could it handle an FMV buyout surprise? For a "maybe keep, maybe rotate" situation like this, the 10% fixed buyout often fits: it protects cash flow compared with a $1 buyout and avoids FMV uncertainty.
Mehmi Financial Group works with over 50 lenders and can compare two lease quotes on the same equipment with different buyouts, so a cheap payment does not turn into an expensive end-of-term problem. Approval, rates and amounts are subject to lender review.
Tools and next steps
- Equipment leases
- Loan vs lease comparison calculator
- $1 buyout vs FMV lease: which to choose
- Sale-leaseback financing in Canada
- Commercial truck financing: loans vs leases
Ready to pick the right buyout for your next lease? Talk to a financing advisor or call 1-833-863-4644.
Disclaimer: This article is general information only and is not tax, legal or accounting advice. Tax rules change and depend on your situation. Speak with a qualified accountant or tax advisor before making any purchase or filing decision. Mehmi Financial Group does not provide tax advice.
Sources
- CRA: Leasing costs
- Justice Laws Website: Income Tax Act, section 16.1
- CRA: Input tax credits
- CRA: Place of supply rules for GST/HST
- Revenu Québec: Leases of road vehicles (GST and QST)
- Prime Minister of Canada: Budget 2025 measures (November 7, 2025)
Written by Jodh Mehmi, Mehmi Financial Group. Read our editorial standards.
Frequently asked questions
Is a $1 buyout always better if I want to own the equipment?
Not always. It is best when you will truly keep the asset long term and can carry the higher payment. If you might upgrade, a fixed or FMV buyout can make exiting easier.
Why is FMV usually cheaper per month?
You are not paying the asset down to near zero. The lessor expects to recover residual value, so you pay for use, with options to return, buy or renew.
What is a fixed buyout in plain English?
A purchase price set at the start, often a percentage of the original cost. It is usually priced between FMV and a $1 buyout on monthly payment.
Do I pay GST/HST on the buyout?
Often, yes, and provincial rules matter. In Quebec, Revenu Québec says GST and QST are collected if the purchase option is exercised on a long-term road vehicle lease.
Can a lease be treated like a financed purchase for tax in Canada?
In some cases. Section 16.1 of the Income Tax Act and CRA guidance allow lease payments to be treated as blended principal and interest with a joint election. Ask your accountant.
What usually delays funding on a lease?
Missing funding conditions: ID, a void cheque or pre-authorized debit form, the insurance certificate or a clean vendor invoice. A deal can be approved but not fundable until the package is complete.
