HomeGuides
Lease vs Loan for Farm Equipment: Compare Five-Year Costs

Lease vs Loan for Farm Equipment: Compare Five-Year Costs

Compare a farm equipment lease and loan using five-year payments, ownership, resale value and the cash needed before harvest.

Written by
Published on
January 16, 2026

Quick answer: Compare a farm equipment lease and loan over five years using the same machine, working hours and end plan. Add every payment and any final amount, then account for equipment value you actually own at year five. Test the cash needed before harvest separately. A lower payment can preserve working cash while leaving a larger purchase amount later.

Disclaimer: This article is general information only and is not tax, legal or accounting advice. Tax rules change and depend on your situation. Speak with a qualified accountant or tax advisor before making any purchase or filing decision. Mehmi Financial Group does not provide tax advice.

Reviewed November 12, 2026.

Key takeaways

  • Choose a year-five outcome before comparing offers: return, keep or sell.
  • Include any loan balance still owing and any lease purchase amount required to own the machine.
  • Use separate estimates for resale value, repair exposure and cash needed during the farm's quiet months.
  • Have an accountant add the relevant tax treatment after the commercial comparison is complete.

Make the two quotes describe the same farm job

Start with the machine and the work. Record the tractor's specification, attachments, expected annual hours and the fields or livestock operation it will serve. A newer leased tractor with dealer support and an older purchased tractor without equivalent coverage are different equipment decisions. You can compare them, but the difference in reliability and service must appear beside the financing numbers.

Ask both providers to use the same equipment price and delivery assumptions where possible. Identify whether an advertised payment includes an advance payment, a trade-in credit or a large final amount. Put the actual trade-in allowance and any debt payout on separate lines. Counting the full trade value as cash available when part of it pays existing debt will overstate your contribution.

Ontario's farm machinery budgeting guidance recommends using farm records to estimate machinery costs and considering annual usage. Apply that approach to fuel, repairs and hours in your comparison. Published averages can help identify missing categories, but your maintenance records and local quotes are better inputs for a specific purchase.

Decide what happens after the fifth season

Write one sentence describing the intended outcome. For example: "After the fifth harvest, we will sell the tractor and replace it." That lets you compare sale proceeds under both structures. If you intend to keep the machine, record its estimated value separately from cash flow, since an unsold tractor does not provide cash for the next payment.

A lease may provide a purchase option, a return route or other end conditions. Read the actual agreement. Obtain the notice deadline, purchase-price method and return standards. A statement that you can upgrade does not explain how the existing obligation will be settled. Ask for a worked settlement showing who receives the old machine and what you still pay.

For a loan extending beyond five years, obtain the scheduled balance at the comparison date. Subtracting resale value from five years of payments while omitting the remaining debt makes the loan look cheaper than it is. If sale requires an early payout, use the applicable payout calculation and fees. Our early payout and buyout guide covers the questions to ask about ending an agreement.

A five-year example with ownership at the end

Suppose a farm compares two invented offers for the same tractor. The loan requires $20,000 upfront and five annual payments of $24,000, after which no debt remains. The lease requires $5,000 upfront, five annual payments of $20,000 and a $40,000 purchase option if the farm wants ownership. Assume both payment schedules occur at year-end. These are arithmetic assumptions, not current market quotes or offered terms.

Assume the farm buys the leased tractor at the end, then sells the machine for $60,000 under either option. Ignore sales taxes, income tax effects, operating costs, fees and the time value of money for this first comparison. The same resale assumption is appropriate only because the equipment and condition are assumed identical.

Illustrative five-year cash comparison in Canadian dollars
Cash itemLoanLease then purchase
Initial payment$20,000$5,000
Five annual payments$120,000$100,000
Final purchase amount$0$40,000
Total paid before sale$140,000$145,000
Assumed sale proceeds($60,000)($60,000)
Net cash outflow$80,000$85,000

The loan uses $5,000 less cash overall under these assumptions. The lease uses $15,000 less at the start and $4,000 less at each annual payment, but requires the $40,000 purchase amount. The farm needs a credible source for that final payment. A hope of refinancing it is an unresolved funding assumption.

If the farm keeps the tractor, its cash outflow remains $140,000 or $145,000 and it retains an asset estimated at $60,000. Do not describe the $80,000 or $85,000 figure as the amount that left the bank unless the assumed sale occurs. Keep the cash schedule and the asset-value comparison on separate pages.

Test resale value and return conditions

Now reduce the assumed resale value to $45,000. The net cash outflows become $95,000 for the loan and $100,000 for lease then purchase. Both increase by $15,000. Buying the leased machine before selling it leaves the farm exposed to the same resale change in this example.

A contractual return option creates a different comparison. If the farm can return the equipment after paying $105,000 in initial and periodic payments, without purchasing it, add actual return expenses and any excess-use charges. Do not subtract a resale value that belongs to the owner. Compare that return cost with the ownership alternative's net sale cost and with the value of any flexibility the agreement genuinely provides.

Request written details on allowed hours, condition inspections, transport, missing attachments and damage. Manitoba Agriculture's lease-or-buy guidance specifically points producers to warranty coverage and charges for exceeding agreed accumulated hours. A well-maintained machine can still create an additional bill if its use exceeds the contract allowance.

Check the month when cash is lowest

A five-year total cannot show whether the spring payment arrives before crop receipts. Build a monthly cash forecast for the first operating year, then repeat it for a weaker season. Use expected collection dates rather than the date you deliver grain or complete contract work. Include seed, fertilizer, payroll, insurance and existing equipment commitments.

For another illustrative test, assume $50,000 of cash before signing and $25,000 of essential expenses before the next dependable receipt. The $20,000 loan contribution leaves $5,000 after those expenses. The $5,000 lease contribution leaves $20,000. Neither result proves affordability: add any payments due before the receipt, contingency repairs and the possibility that the receipt is late.

If the loan is cheaper overall but leaves an inadequate reserve, ask whether a different contribution or payment schedule is available. Compare the revised total and remaining debt. For a lease, plan the final purchase fund from the beginning. Our seasonal farm payment guide explains how to match payment dates to receipts.

Add repairs and tax treatment without counting costs twice

Check what service is actually included in each quote. A warranty, maintenance plan and replacement-machine commitment answer different questions. Ask who pays travel time, wear items and transport to the workshop, and what happens during a breakdown at harvest. Obtain the terms rather than assuming leasing includes maintenance.

Use an additional row for costs that differ between the alternatives. If both require the same fuel and routine maintenance, keep those amounts in the affordability budget but recognize that they may not change the choice. Avoid adding a repair reserve to the comparison and then also treating the entire reserve as an actual repair expense.

Tax treatment needs its own calculation. The CRA's leasing-cost guidance describes business leasing deductions and an election that can change treatment in qualifying circumstances. Give your accountant both agreements, expected business use and the planned sale or purchase date. Do not carry a deduction percentage or first-year incentive from an older example into the decision.

Ask the accountant to show when any deduction or recoverable sales tax affects cash, alongside tax on disposal where relevant. If timing could change the result, request a discounted cash-flow comparison with an explained discount rate. The simple totals above deliberately omit that calculation and cannot establish an after-tax winner.

Frequently asked questions

Does a lower annual lease payment mean a lower cost?

No. Check the initial amount, final purchase price and return obligations. In the example, annual lease payments are lower but acquiring the same ownership outcome costs $5,000 more before the excluded items.

Can I count the tractor's value if I keep it?

You can include an estimated retained value in an economic comparison. Label it clearly and keep it out of available cash. Support the estimate with comparable equipment, condition and hours, and test a lower value.

What if I expect to use the tractor for ten years?

Extend the comparison to that holding period. Include years after the first agreement ends, expected repairs and any replacement financing. A five-year calculation may favour an arrangement that costs more over the full working life you actually need.

Tools and next steps

Collect both written quotes, a payment calendar, equipment details and the intended end outcome. Mark every unknown amount before choosing. Use the farm equipment application guide to prepare documents. Mehmi considers startup businesses with at least six months of revenue supported by bank statements; equipment and application review still determine available terms.

For a financing discussion, contact Mehmi Financial Group or call 1-833-863-4644 with both offers and your seasonal cash forecast.

Disclaimer: This article is general information only and is not tax, legal or accounting advice. Tax rules change and depend on your situation. Speak with a qualified accountant or tax advisor before making any purchase or filing decision. Mehmi Financial Group does not provide tax advice.

Sources

By Jodhbir Mehmi. Read our editorial standards.

Frequently asked questions

Apply Now

YOUR NEXT STEP WITH MEHMI

Ready to move forward?

Choose the path that fits your role. Whether you're seeking capital, selling equipment, or placing a client file, start in the right place.

FOR BUSINESS OWNERS

Find financing for your next move.

Buying equipment, refinancing, or managing cash flow? Share your amount, purpose, and timeline so we can review potential options.

Get Financing Options →

For businesses looking for capital

FOR EQUIPMENT VENDORS

Give more buyers a way forward.

Offer financing as part of your sales process and help customers move ahead without building your own lending operation.

Explore Vendor Financing →

For dealers, distributors & manufacturers

FOR BROKERS & ISOs

Have a commercial file to place?

Explore Mehmi's broker program for equipment and business financing submissions and working with our team.

Explore Broker Program →

For commercial finance professionals

This guide is general information, not financial, legal or tax advice. Read our editorial standards.

Explore your industry

Find guidance for your sector and how your business operates.

9 industries · Swipe or use the arrows to see them all.

Transportation & logistics

Explore financing considerations for carriers, logistics businesses and freight operations.

Explore industry →

Construction & contractors

Plan around project costs, contract timing and day-to-day business needs.

Explore industry →

Manufacturing & wholesale

Explore financing for production, order cycles and wholesale operations.

Explore industry →

Farming & agriculture

Consider seasonal cash flow, operating needs and long-term farm investment.

Explore industry →

Restaurants & hospitality

Explore financing for food-service businesses, hospitality operations and growth.

Explore industry →

Medical, dental & wellness

Plan financing around practice operations, patient services and business expansion.

Explore industry →

Technology & business services

Explore financing considerations for project delivery, hiring and growth.

Explore industry →

Forestry, mining & energy

Consider contract cycles, operating requirements and investment in resource businesses.

Explore industry →

Aviation & marine

Explore financing considerations for commercial aviation and marine operations.

Explore industry →