Differences Between Capital and Operating Leases

Leasing equipment, vehicles, or machinery is a smart way for businesses to access essential assets without large upfront investments. But not all leases are created equal. If you’re comparing options for your next truck, trailer, or heavy equipment acquisition, understanding the difference between a capital lease and an operating lease is essential.

This guide breaks down both types of leases and helps Canadian business owners make the right decision based on financial goals, asset needs, and tax implications.

Mehmi Financial Group offers flexible leasing and financing options across Canada — from long-term capital leases to short-term operating leases — tailored for industries like transportation, construction, healthcare, and manufacturing.

What Is a Lease?

A lease is a legal agreement where a business (the lessee) pays to use an asset owned by another party (the lessor) for a fixed period. The lease allows the business to operate or generate income with the asset without purchasing it outright.

There are two main lease types in Canada:

• Capital lease (finance lease): mimics ownership
• Operating lease: resembles a rental agreement

What Is a Capital Lease?

A capital lease, also known as a finance lease, is a long-term leasing arrangement where the business essentially acquires ownership of the asset by the end of the lease. It’s treated as if the business purchased the asset using borrowed funds.

Key Features of a Capital Lease

• Ownership Transfer: Most capital leases include an option to purchase the asset at the end of the term, sometimes for a nominal fee.
• Long-Term Agreement: These leases usually span the majority of the asset’s useful life.
• Balance Sheet Impact: Capital leases are recorded as both an asset and a liability on your balance sheet.
• Accounting Treatment: You must record depreciation on the asset and interest on the liability.
• Tax Benefits: Interest and depreciation may be deductible, depending on your business structure and tax strategy.

When to Use a Capital Lease

Choose this option when:

• You plan to keep the asset long term
• You want to build equity in the asset
• You're comfortable with added balance sheet visibility

What Is an Operating Lease?

An operating lease is a short-term rental agreement where you use the asset temporarily, with no ownership transfer. It’s ideal for assets that depreciate quickly or become obsolete over time.

Key Features of an Operating Lease

• No Ownership: At lease end, you return the asset to the lessor
• Shorter Terms: Often used for equipment or vehicles needed for 12–36 months
• Off-Balance-Sheet: Payments are recorded as business expenses, not as assets or liabilities
• Simplified Accounting: No need to track depreciation or interest

When to Use an Operating Lease

Consider this lease if:

• You want to upgrade assets frequently
• The asset has a short useful life
• You want to keep liabilities off your balance sheet

Side-by-Side Comparison: Capital Lease vs. Operating Lease

How to Choose the Right Lease Type

Choosing between a capital and operating lease depends on your business goals and the specific asset you're acquiring.

1. Evaluate Your Asset Needs

Ask yourself:

• Is this a long-term asset I want to own?
• Will I need to replace it in 2–3 years due to technology or industry change?

If ownership and longevity matter, lean toward a capital lease. If flexibility and mobility matter, consider an operating lease.

2. Consider Financial Reporting Impact

A capital lease increases assets and liabilities — this may affect your debt-to-equity ratio. An operating lease, on the other hand, keeps liabilities off your books but adds ongoing expenses to your income statement.

3. Analyze Tax and Cash Flow Effects

• Capital lease: Eligible for depreciation and interest deductions
• Operating lease: Entire payment often tax deductible as an expense

Work with your accountant to understand the impact on taxable income and cash flow.

4. Review Lease Terms in Detail

Ensure you understand:

• End-of-lease options
• Hidden fees or mileage limits (especially for vehicles)
• Early termination clauses
• Buyout structures for capital leases

Real-World Example: Truck Leasing in Canada

Let’s say a trucking business is choosing between leasing a Class 8 semi-truck or financing it outright.

• A capital lease makes sense if the business wants to own the truck after 5 years, gain equity, and depreciate the asset
• An operating lease is better if they want to upgrade vehicles every 2–3 years to newer models with better fuel efficiency

Explore Mehmi Financial Group’s flexible truck leasing solutions here:
Financing & Leasing Services

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Is a capital lease considered debt?
Yes. It’s reported as a liability on your balance sheet and treated similarly to a loan.

Can I get a capital lease with bad credit?
It depends. A larger down payment or using the asset as collateral can improve approval chances. Mehmi Financial Group works with clients across the credit spectrum.

Do operating leases affect credit?
While not shown as debt, lenders may still factor lease obligations into debt-service calculations.

Which lease has lower monthly payments?
Typically, operating leases have lower monthly payments since you’re not financing the full value for ownership.

Conclusion

Understanding the difference between capital and operating leases is vital for making sound financial decisions in your business. A capital lease gives you long-term control and ownership, while an operating lease offers flexibility and lower short-term costs.

At Mehmi Financial Group, we help you choose the lease structure that aligns with your cash flow, growth plans, and operational needs. Whether you need trucks, trailers, or heavy equipment, our financing experts will guide you through every step.

Speak with a leasing expert

Contact our team to compare lease options or apply now and get matched with a lease that fits your business needs.

‍